Theories of Rights: Exploring Hohfeld's Analysis
LegalStix Law School

Theories of Rights: Exploring Hohfeld's Analysis

Download FREE LegalStix App

Rights are a fundamental concept in legal discourse, but their meaning can often be elusive. While the law aims to arbitrate between diverse claims and harmonize them, individuals perceive rights from their own perspective. 

About Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld

Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld was a prominent legal scholar born in California in 1879. He graduated from the University of California and later became the editor of the Harvard Law Review while studying at Harvard Law School. Hohfeld's seminal work, "Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning and Other Legal Essays," along with his contributions to the Yale Law Journal, encapsulates his jurisprudence.

Hohfeld's analysis continues to be highly influential, even a century after his death. His theories have left a lasting impact on the Indian legal justice system and are still relevant today.

A Primer to Hohfeld's Analysis

According to Hohfeld, a "right" is a legal interest that imposes a correlative duty. For example, if X has a right against Y to keep off Y's land, the correlative duty is that Y has an obligation to stay off the place. Hohfeld also emphasizes the distinction between rights and other legal interests, such as privileges, powers, and immunities.

Hohfeld's analysis is based on the usage of correlatives and opposites. He proposes separating rights, privileges, powers, and immunities, as they are distinct legal interests with different legal duties. This distinction is based on the duties these interests place on other individuals or entities.

Jural Relations

Hohfeld's dissatisfaction with the reduction of all legal relations to rights and duties led him to develop the concept of jural relations. These relations can be best understood through the following table:

Jural RelationsCorrelativesOpposites

The table illustrates the relationships between different legal positions. Vertical arrows connect jural correlatives, which entail each other, while diagonal arrows connect jural opposites, which deny each other.

Rights and Duties

Hohfeld distinguishes between rights and duties, emphasizing that the term "rights" is often misapplied to other legal interests. According to him, rights are always accompanied by legal obligations. For example, if X has a right against Y to keep off X's land, Y has a duty to stay away from X's territory.

The term "claim" is the most accurate synonym for "right" in terms of meaning. A claim implies legal protection from interference or refusal to provide aid in connection with a certain action or state of affairs. It also imposes a responsibility on others to refrain from interfering or provide aid or recompense.

Privileges and No-Rights

Hohfeld distinguishes between privileges and no-rights, although the term "liberty" is often preferred by later jurists. Privileges are permissions to act in a certain way without being held liable for harm caused to others. The correlative relationship between privileges and no-rights demonstrates that the person against whom a privilege is asserted has no right to interfere with the action.

It is important to note that liberties that are not accompanied by responsibilities imposed on others exist in legal systems for various political reasons. For example, fundamental rights mentioned in the Indian Constitution are privileges that provide the state with a "no-right" to interfere in the exercise of these freedoms.

Powers and Liabilities

Hohfeld introduces the concept of powers and liabilities as second-order relations. Powers are legal abilities that allow a person to change jural relations in a specific way. For example, a person with the power to transfer property can change the legal relationship between two individuals regarding that property. Liabilities, on the other hand, refer to the susceptibility to someone exercising power.

Hohfeld provides several examples of legal powers, such as property-related powers, contractual obligation-creating capabilities, and the establishment of an agency relationship. Liabilities can be both pleasant and unpleasant, depending on the specific circumstances.

Immunities and Disabilities

Immunity refers to the state of not being able to have one's rights altered by another. Disabilities, on the other hand, refer to a lack of power to change legal entitlements. Immunities and disabilities are similar to the contrast between rights and privileges. Immunity rights are commonly found in constitutional texts, ensuring that certain entitlements cannot be interfered with by the state.

For example, if the constitution guarantees freedom of speech, the legislature cannot wield any power in this regard. While the legislature is disabled, the people have immunity rights to freedom of speech.

Criticism of Hohfeld's Theory of Rights

Hohfeld's analysis has been both praised and criticized by legal philosophers. Some argue that his analysis provides a model of conceptual clarity and rigor, while others question the universality of rights/duties correlativity. However, even critics acknowledge the value of Hohfeld's analysis in preventing conceptual errors in legal discourse.

The Requirement of Two People for Hohfeldian Analysis of Rights

According to Hohfeld's analysis, rights should be relations between two distinct individuals. Consequently, there is no such thing as a "right to bodily integrity." Instead, one person (X) has a claim-right to a certain content against another person (Y). The number of rights is determined by the number of individuals holding them and those against whom they are held.

Hohfeld's framework distinguishes between "paucital rights" (rights of similar substance held against many persons) and "multital rights" (rights held against all people). However, it is important to remember that Hohfeld's basic atomic rights exist exclusively between two individuals.

Hohfeld's Primary Correlativity Claim

Hohfeld's primary correlativity claim states that the correlative of every passive right is a duty on the part of others to perform the act that is the content of the passive right. While this claim has been contested, it remains crucial to Hohfeld's rights analysis.

Functions of Rights: Will Theory and Interest Theory

In jurisprudence, there are two main theories regarding the function of rights: the will theory and the interest theory.

Will Theory

The will theory, also known as the choice theory, argues that having a right gives its possessor power over another's responsibilities. Will theorists claim that rights make individuals "small-scale sovereigns." For example, a property owner has the power to waive or transfer the duties of others. Similarly, a promisee has the power to annul the promisor's obligation to fulfill the promise.

Interest Theory

The interest theory, favored by interest theorists, argues that the function of a right is to serve the right interests. According to this theory, individuals have rights because possession benefits them. For example, property ownership benefits the owner, and promisees have a right because they have an interest in the promise's fulfillment or in making voluntary ties with others.

Analysis of the Functions of Rights

Both the will theory and the interest theory have their own perspectives on the ultimate purpose of rights, means of protection, and the types of normative positions that constitute rights. While the will theory emphasizes power and choice, the interest theory focuses on the benefits and interests of individuals.


Hohfeld's analysis of rights provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the complex nature of legal relationships. By distinguishing between different legal interests, such as rights, privileges, powers, and immunities, Hohfeld clarifies the concepts that are often conflated. While his analysis has both supporters and critics, it remains a valuable tool for legal discourse.

Stay updated with the latest insights on legal topics by visiting Legalstix Law School.

Loading Result...

Download FREE LegalStix App

Get instant updates!

Request a callback
Register Now